Picking the Right Recruiting Agency

It might surprise some that SalesFirst Recruiting doesn’t spend a lot of time on sales. Truthfully, we don’t need to do much selling these days—our customers come to us frequently. Occasionally though, prospective clients tell us they want to evaluate other firms before selecting us. While this is normal for buyers and shoppers, it’s actually not very common for us. So, while this reflects how we've done things right since our launch in 2012, we thought we’d take the opportunity to write about how to choose your recruiting agency. If you're looking to partner with a recruiting service that truly delivers, it’s essential to evaluate their credibility thoroughly. Here’s how we believe companies should gauge the credibility of a recruiting service:

1. Prioritize Referred Agencies

Start by considering agencies that come recommended by trusted sources. At SalesFirst Recruiting, our long-standing relationships and referrals speak volumes about our reputation. Longstanding agencies have built years of goodwill based on trust and hard work. While issues are inevitable, the ability of an agency to handle them and make things right strengthens their credibility.

2. Check Their Track Record

Examine the recruiting service’s history. Look for:

  • Experience and Longevity: A service with a long-standing presence is often a sign of reliability. SalesFirst’s long track record demonstrates our stability and expertise.

  • Methodical Growth: Look for signs of steady, methodical growth. SalesFirst Recruiting’s approach to evolving its processes and learning from experiences ensures a reliable and continuously improving service.

  • Avoid “Suddenly-Huge” Agencies: This is something we’ve only noticed lately. A new agency will pop up with an eye-popping advertising budget and 60+ recruiters ready to get to work. Seems exciting. Even for us. But we’ve since seen the truth- the winners are the VC investors who demand fast returns at the cost of quality.

3. Assess Their Industry Knowledge

A credible recruiting service should have deep knowledge of your industry. At SalesFirst Recruiting, we’ve specialized in sales recruitment from the start. Evaluate their:

  • Specialization: Ensure they specialize in your sector, because a well-connected recruiter can access top talent. Our extensive network has been a key factor in our success since our inception. Hold all firms to this level of scrutiny.

4. Review Their Recruitment Process

A transparent and effective recruitment process is a hallmark of a reputable service. Look into:

  • Candidate Screening: Reputable agencies take candidate screening seriously and put their reputation on the line with every candidate submission. Be wary of agencies promising volume, as this might indicate a loose process.

  • Communication: Regular updates and feedback are crucial. At SalesFirst, we pride ourselves on our open lines of communication throughout the recruitment process, including scheduled weekly or biweekly check-ins.

5. Evaluate Their Reputation and Community Commitment

Research their reputation within the industry and their commitment to the community. SalesFirst Recruiting is actively involved in community initiatives, reinforcing our accountability. This can be done by:

  • Online Reviews: Check for reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, or industry-specific forums.

  • Professional Associations: Membership in relevant professional associations can indicate credibility.

  • Community Engagement: Look for signs of the recruiter's commitment to the community. SalesFirst Recruiting’s involvement in local initiatives reflects our dedication to maintaining a positive reputation.

6. Look for Employee Return Rates and Transparency

Consider these additional factors to assess credibility:

  • Employee Tenure: Companies that retain their employees tend to conduct business ethically. Unethical companies often experience high turnover.

  • Employee Return Rates: Companies with a positive work environment often see employees return after leaving. SalesFirst Recruiting’s positive work environment reflects our strong company culture and employee satisfaction.

  • Transparency: Evaluate how transparent the company is about its team. SalesFirst Recruiting features all of our employees, including ownership, on our website, showcasing our commitment to openness and accountability.

7. Assess Their Approach to Understanding Your Needs

A reputable recruiting service will seek to understand your specific needs before proposing their model or pricing. At SalesFirst Recruiting, our intake process is VERY thorough—anything less would be doing you a disservice. Look for:

  • Initial Engagement: Good recruiting agencies take the time to learn about your company, the role you’re hiring for, and your ideal candidate profile before quoting you a price or pitching a model. SalesFirst Recruiting tailors its approach based on your needs, ensuring a more effective and personalized service.

8. Analyze Their Contract Terms

Before signing any agreement, scrutinize their contract terms. While understanding their pricing model is important, it should not be the sole basis for comparison. Be wary of selecting agencies solely based on pricing, as this approach can lead to choosing less reputable, fly-by-night agencies. Focus instead on:

  • Fee Structure: Ensure the fees are clear and at market rate for the services provided. Quality agencies typically charge a range of 20% - 30% of guaranteed income. SalesFirst’s average fee is 25%.

9. Evaluate Recruiter Compensation Structure

Consider how the recruiting agency compensates its recruiters. A balanced compensation structure, such as base salary plus commission, ensures that recruiters are incentivized for success but not so desperate that they will say or do anything just to close a deal. This approach aligns their interests with yours, leading to more genuine and effective recruitment efforts.

10. Ask for Referrals

Finally, ask for referrals from other businesses or industry contacts. Personal recommendations can provide valuable insights into the reliability and effectiveness of the recruiting service. SalesFirst Recruiting’s reputation is built on referrals and word-of-mouth from satisfied clients.

Conclusion

Choosing a credible recruiting service is crucial for finding the right talent and ensuring a smooth hiring process. By prioritizing referred agencies, evaluating their track record, industry knowledge, recruitment process, reputation, community commitment, employee return rates, thorough approach to understanding your needs, contract terms, and recruiter compensation structure, you can make an informed decision that supports your company's growth and success. SalesFirst Recruiting, with our decade-long expertise and commitment to excellence, serves as a model of what to look for in a top-notch recruiting partner.

Previous
Previous

Why "First, Break All the Rules" is a Must-Read for New Sales Managers

Next
Next

Will Your Employees Stay or Leave in 2025?